CS 4723 · Software Validation and Quality Assurance
with Xiaoyin Wang
Across 3 sections of CS 4723, Xiaoyin Wang's median grade was A. No one else has taught it.
Compare in Analytical ModeMedian Grade in CS 4723A
BluebookUTSA course evaluations · 2 sections
Instructor4.4 / 5
Course4.3 / 5
Rate My ProfessorsSee all ratings
Rating3.8 / 5
Difficulty4.0 / 5
Would take again80%
Grade breakdown55 grades
Average GPA3.47
A's62%
D's and F's4%
Withdrew4%
Latest syllabus
Fall 2025
Grades in CS 4723
62%
A
24%
B
7%
C
0%
D
4%
F
4%
W
Every grade
| Grade | Students | Percent |
|---|---|---|
| A+ | 5 | 9% |
| A | 24 | 44% |
| A- | 5 | 9% |
| B+ | 7 | 13% |
| B | 4 | 7% |
| B- | 2 | 4% |
| C+ | 2 | 4% |
| C | 2 | 4% |
| F | 2 | 4% |
| W | 2 | 4% |
Percentages are out of everyone who got a letter grade or withdrew (W). IN, IW, and IF are incompletes.
Every semester
Fall 2025
Median B+17 gradesBluebook 4.2 / 5
Fall 2023
Median A8 gradesBluebook 4.5 / 5
Fall 2022
Median A30 grades
What students say
- CS4723“Appreciate that he recorded lectures, although he can be slow to post them. The first project is a lot of work so try to start early. Might need to look up how to run JUnit Tests on your own, and follow his class Fibonacci demo. Midterm was harder than expected but seemed to curve a little. Would take again, is a nice professor.”
- CS4723“Validation as a class is known to be boring, but I enjoyed going to his lectures. He recorded them so reviewing for the exams was super helpful. His second project was actively being built during the semester, and it was missing critical steps and really difficult to build, even following the directions. Slow project grades. Both exams went well.”
- CS-5363“Compilers seems to be a UTSA graduate CS gateway course for whatever reason (why? It's not useful for most of CS). The project is very difficult and confusing, especially the final part. Having the project at least compile and run will go far, even w/errors. He doesn't respond to many emails, & grades hard on tests, but has a little curve overall.”
- CS-5363“If you are struggling with the project, good luck. His emails were helpful with directing what to do, but that's when he actually does respond. Brutal on the exams, especially on questions like automata and miss one thing on it. Hopefully if the catalog is changing, this class would become optional, and I recommend against taking this class.”
- CS-3773“I took this class in the summer. It was very organized. The professor did a good job of laying out all the requirements. The Professor also did a good job of balancing direct slide reading with further explainations and experiences. Test reviews were helpful and there were no surprises. The project was fun, and I learned new skills ! Great job !”